Ethan Matlin's iMedia: The Test
Summary: Ethan had a video about how our educational system was focused on the all-mighty test, one that does not focus on the arts or rational thinking in general nearly as much as it should. He believes that if we were to put more emphasis on this, then the American system would be greatly improved, strengthening the country.
My comment: This was a very nice post, even though the tune from that video is probably going to be stuck in my head for the rest of the day.
A couple things came into my head when I was reading this. First of all, I thought a lot about that little animation we watched last year in Social Studies about how our educational system is completely outdated, and how it should be reformed. One problem I found with both your video and the animation was that it didn't really address any possible solutions to this problem. Not that there is anything wrong with just raising awareness to a problem, but I could honestly not think of any way to hold schools, students, and teachers accountable without a test.
Secondly, one thing I think also needs to be pointed out is that this is not just an American problem- actually, it is anything but that. My parents were educated in India, so I have the priviledge of being able to talk to them about the educational system there and here, and the biggest thing that I hear from them (and, in fact, all of my family) is that, yeah, the system there is really good, because you learn all the necessary formulas, all the concepts, what everything is... but you are stuck there. You never really learn how to learn, how to think. The same is true for much of East Asia, where memorization is key. The problem may be pretty bad here, and there is definitely a lot of improvement needed, but the system we have, in terms of teaching thinking, is much better than much of the world.
Finally, and ironically enough, the video and your response reminded me a lot about something Confucius once said. He said that "he who thinks and does not study is in great danger; he who studies and does not think is lost." I feel like that comment is at the very center of all that you and Chapin were trying to say about our system. It might be a good idea to start looking to him if we want to fix our educational system in a way that best fits our society as it stands.
Very nice job.
Jacob Levin's Get Organized: DVD Cabinet
Summary: In cleaning out his DVD cabinet, Jacob learned that organization makes you feel like you're in control of your life and that organization is an ongoing process, not just a one-and-done thing. He also did not appear to be fond of Ndamukong Suh.
My response: First of all, (Mr. Allen, please skip the rest of this sentence) who does like Suh?
With that being said, this was a very nicely written post. I almost felt as if you were right next to me; I could even hear you reading in your "density" voice at certain points.
One thing that you touched on a little bit that I would like to expound on a bit is related to something Aristotle once said. He said that "we are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit." I think that this was really at the heart of what you were saying at the end of your essay about how to keep your cabinet organized, you would have to continuously organize it or teach yourself better organization habits. Only in this way would you truly become excellent at your organization.
At this point, someone else might wonder why it matters if you are amazing at organizing your DVD cabinets. I would argue that you brought up why it matters earlier in your post, when you mentioned that your organization project made you feel more in control of your life. While it may be a lot of work teaching yourself new habits, organizing repeatedly, and becoming an excellent organizer and a better person, in the end, it will make you feel more accomplished and in control of your life. I would also argue that, eventually, these behaviors, if you keep them up, will spill over into other aspects of your life (such as organizing your room- sorry, I just couldn't resist). In other words, this little step you took by organizing your DVD cabinet may very well make you a much better and happier person than you could have anticipated.
It appears that Aristotle actually knew what he was talking about when he stressed the importance of organization.
Just a thought.
PS: My guess for the Super Bowl: Giants 27, Patriots 24
No comments:
Post a Comment