Saturday, September 17, 2011

Best of the Week: The Fluidity of Writing

I think the most important idea brought up this week was Mr. A----'s observation about one of the passages in Orlando. It was an unseasonably chilly, cloudy Thursday- one of those days that you wake up in the morning and start praying that your alarm clock is running fast. We had about a half-hour left in class, and we were trying to find a passage that we could discuss when J^^^^ found the section with Orlando's epiphany and shared it with the class.

After J^^^^ read the passage out loud, Mr. A---- gave a tiny sigh, smiled, leaned back in his "pretentious" chair, and asked us what we could comment on about the writing of the passage. As usual, the class jumped into the thick of it all, attempting to analyze everything from the themes demonstrated in the passage to whether it was a treatise or an essay, when Mr. A---- just smiled a bit wider and essentially told us that we were doing a great job, but doing it wrong. He wanted to know what was distinctive about the writing of the passage, not so much the passage itself. We just stared blankly back at him with a half smile, wondering why he wouldn't dot the i on the board.

Then it seemed as if someone had a revelation and commented that Woolf used a lot of semicolons in her sentence, and after that, the floodgates just seemed to come open. Suddenly, ideas about her writing style for that passage just started flowing out of our mouths (or, more accurately, everyone else's mouth). Everything down to the very placement of the words seemed important to the feeling that was being conveyed.

Now that I was thinking about it, through that whole passage, without even realizing it, I had been holding my breath, feeling the emotion flowing out of the pages like heat flowing out of the thermite reaction. I suddenly realized exactly where I had last felt that same sudden surge of emotion that managed to stop a phlegmatic thing like me cold in my tracks- the scene where Yossarian went AWOL in the slums of Rome in one of my favorite books of all time, Catch-22. When I read that, I had managed to register a feeling that I wasn't quite able to put a name to, but, completely enthralled, I decided that it wasn't very important and moved on. I later decided to attribute that feeling to the plot, but now, I was realizing that the plot actually had very little to do with that feeling compared to the style of writing that was employed, filling the section with relatively short, choppy sentences to cause the writing to be unsettling. I now saw that Virginia Woolf was employing the exact same tactic in reverse- she was using a long, flowing sentence to make us feel excited.

Looking back, it might seem almost absurd that this came as such a revelation to me, but what one has to understand is that we (or at least I) never really paid much attention to how musically passages in literature were written. Usually, our study of literature was limited to analyzing themes, and our study of writing was almost entirely about the laws of writing and what was and wasn't legal to do. We touched on the subject of fluidity and musicality of writing last year with Life of Pi, but we really didn't talk much about anything but Yann Martel's stream of conciousness.

From this revelation, I now feel I have a better understanding of a crucial part of writing that makes it literature in the first place, which is its sheer brilliance at telling a story, but I think that an even bigger benefit from understanding this would be that I can now actually use this in my own writing. After all, isn't that one of the main purposes of reading literatue- to help us improve our own writing?

It never fails to amaze me how much insight a simple, 15-minute discussion on a single, isolated point can give you.

Friday, September 9, 2011

Captured Thought: The Orlando Questions

Unfortunately, I just didn't get it.

Even after going through the reading, searching with increasing confusion for the answer, it seemed to just keep eluding me.

It was a Friday night, and I was just sitting in front of the computer, a book placed upside-down right in front of me. I was just staring at the screen, almost wishing that the words on the screen would transform themselves into something that I could make some sense out of. To my disappointment, they didn't, so I decided to try thinking about the questions again.

I sighed and looked back in my copy of Orlando, trying to figure out exactly what any of the Study and Discussion questions had to do with the first section of Orlando. Granted, there were a few questions that I could understand, and there were a few that dealt with things that hadn't occured yet, but there was one question in particular that I knew was a part of the section we had read, but I could not make head or tail of. How was I supposed to know how clothes affect our identity? Clothes are clothes, I thought, nothing more.

Irritated, I just decided to give up and hope that I didn't have to talk about it when we were discussing the reading in class.

Four days came and went, taking with them the long weekend and a day of Orlando discussions. Now, we were being split up into five groups and being assigned questions to discuss in those groups, then present before the class. As Mr. ----- assigned the questions to the groups, I started praying to God-knows-who that I wouldn't be assigned to the clothing question. I held my breath and waited to hear what our group would discuss.

Three guesses what question we got.

Trying not to show my mixture of irritation at my (apparent) bad luck and despair at my situation, I sat down with the group and began trying to get a conversation going. For better or for worse, everyone in my group seemed to be in the same boat as I was. Quickly, the discussion turned quite simplistic and prosaic, and we just began grasping at straws. Finally, someone brought up, almost by pure chance, how in-depth Sasha's clothes were described in the book. With nothing else to really think about than that, I turned idly to that page and reread that section.

I suddenly felt so enlightened that I nearly forgot to breathe.

Something had just fallen into place in my brain. I suddenly realized exactly how the clothes and their affect on one's identity were being presented. Rereading the passage, I realized that Sasha, when Orlando first saw her, was dressed in such a way that Orlando, upon first sight, was actually unable to determine her gender- he thought she was a male, and in presenting herself like that, she took on the traditional male role in a relationship- as the dominant one. Wait... presentation! That was it! Our clothes are the way we presented ourselves to the rest of the world, and that presentation actually became what we are.

All of this occured in my mind in a fraction of a second, so it came as somewhat of a surprise to the rest of my group when I brutally wedged myself into the increasingly mundane discussion with a gasp, followed by me rambling about clothes and identities and Sasha and gender roles and, once, a massive "Oh my god!"

Gradually, though, they began to understand what I was trying to get across, and I slowly started realizing exactly how I had come up with that idea. The concept that I had just understood actually seemed to have come from a comment that Ch***** had made the day before, when she mentioned that throughout the whole Sasha-Orlando romance, Orlando had really been under Sasha's thumb the whole time. She cited the fact that Sasha cheated on him, got him to do whatever she wanted, and, in the end, dumped him and went back to Russia.

Shortly after this, I made the logical jump that the traditional gender roles in this relationship were switched, and made some (albeit minute) note of how their clothes also reflected this, but for some reason- possibly that I had actually managed to block that question out of my mind- I couldn't make the relatively tiny jump to my second day epiphany until I actually sat down and specifially thought about it.

Regardless, it was with some satisfaction that we were able to give a relatively coherent and (if I do say so myself) thoughtful presentation to the class. I realized that, not for the first time, I had actually gleaned some new insight from a discussion. I had almost forgotten how great it felt.