Comment on Nina's "Dialectics: Systems and Freedom"
Summary: In this blog, Nina analyzes the dynamics between being in the system of the Matrix and being liberated from it. She notes that while one may have absolute control over their own lives outside of the Matrix, it would appear to be a much happier and easier life within the Matrix, with much less hardship and many more choices than the "real world."
My Comment: Nina, this was a very well written,
thought-provoking blog entry. I really enjoyed reading this.
Rohan's Academy Blog
Understanding the world one math problem at a time
Friday, May 11, 2012
Sunday, May 6, 2012
Dialectics: Truth and Perception
Over the course of The Matrix, there was a very interesting dialectic introduced between truth and perception. The dialectic seems to focus mostly on which is more important and more fulfilling, with different arguments being raised by everyone from Neo to Agent Smith, from Morpheus to Cipher.
Arguing on the side of truth being more important were Morpheus and Neo. Their primary argument for truth being superior to perception was simply that perception is a tool to keep us enslaved, and the truth is the only thing that can set us free.
Over the course of the movie, though there are problems with learning the truth, such as constant danger, discomforting knowledge, and physical privations, there was still a very strong case being made for the truth to be more important. Not only did it free one from the control of the machines, but it also freed them from the rules.
To Morpheus and Neo, that was probably the most important. With the truth, they were able to see through the normal rules of the Matrix and to essentially do whatever they wanted. They could fly, they could learn at a moment's notice, they could be lightning-fast and impossibly strong. They could doge bullets or take seven shots at point-blank range and still get up, all because the truth freed them from the rules.
To everyone in the movie who chose the truth over perception, they saw both the good and the bad of the world, and they chose to focus on the good that came out of their decision. However, there were several characters in the movie who chose to focus on the bad side of learning the truth, primarily Cipher and Agent Smith.
To them, the truth was not nearly as important as what the perception of the truth was, their argument being that it doesn't matter if you are enslaved, so long as you are a happy slave.
We saw this in especially sharp relief when Cipher was in a secret meeting with Agent Smith, talking about how he wanted to go back into the Matrix, saying that he realized after his time on the bleak, privation-filled ship that "ignorance is bliss." He doesn't care that he will have to follow the rules like everyone else. He just sees that those who see the truth are dissatisfied, and he chooses to go back to only seeing perception and becoming satisfied once more.
In the end, the Matrix seems to agree with John Stuart Mills, saying that it is better to see the unsatisfactory truth than to be a perception-filled pig satisfied. This dialectic opened by The Matrix, however, has many other practical applications aw well.
For example, this can throw into question whether or not scientific progress is really all that great after all. Centuries ago, the perception of the world around us was that God controlled everything, and you had to be good for the world around us to be good. People believed that. People dedicated their lives to that. People held a fear of God, and they, for the most part, acted morally and as good members of society. Their understanding may not have been good, but their lives were fulfilling.
Now, however, we can see far more of the truth. We know infinitely more than the people centuries ago did, leading us to believe that God does not control everything. Many people have stopped holding that fear of God, many have chosen to drop out of the society as a result, and in many cases, morality seems to have taken the back burner to other issues. Yes, our understanding of science is greater, and we see far more of the truth, but we need to ask ourselves: is the societal damage worth it?
This is simply an offshoot that we can think about analyzing based off the dialectic between truth and perception in The Matrix. While The Matrix is not the be-all-end-all, it nonetheless presents a very important dialogue that we should have to make our lives as fulfilling as possible.
Arguing on the side of truth being more important were Morpheus and Neo. Their primary argument for truth being superior to perception was simply that perception is a tool to keep us enslaved, and the truth is the only thing that can set us free.
Over the course of the movie, though there are problems with learning the truth, such as constant danger, discomforting knowledge, and physical privations, there was still a very strong case being made for the truth to be more important. Not only did it free one from the control of the machines, but it also freed them from the rules.
To Morpheus and Neo, that was probably the most important. With the truth, they were able to see through the normal rules of the Matrix and to essentially do whatever they wanted. They could fly, they could learn at a moment's notice, they could be lightning-fast and impossibly strong. They could doge bullets or take seven shots at point-blank range and still get up, all because the truth freed them from the rules.
To everyone in the movie who chose the truth over perception, they saw both the good and the bad of the world, and they chose to focus on the good that came out of their decision. However, there were several characters in the movie who chose to focus on the bad side of learning the truth, primarily Cipher and Agent Smith.
To them, the truth was not nearly as important as what the perception of the truth was, their argument being that it doesn't matter if you are enslaved, so long as you are a happy slave.
We saw this in especially sharp relief when Cipher was in a secret meeting with Agent Smith, talking about how he wanted to go back into the Matrix, saying that he realized after his time on the bleak, privation-filled ship that "ignorance is bliss." He doesn't care that he will have to follow the rules like everyone else. He just sees that those who see the truth are dissatisfied, and he chooses to go back to only seeing perception and becoming satisfied once more.
In the end, the Matrix seems to agree with John Stuart Mills, saying that it is better to see the unsatisfactory truth than to be a perception-filled pig satisfied. This dialectic opened by The Matrix, however, has many other practical applications aw well.
For example, this can throw into question whether or not scientific progress is really all that great after all. Centuries ago, the perception of the world around us was that God controlled everything, and you had to be good for the world around us to be good. People believed that. People dedicated their lives to that. People held a fear of God, and they, for the most part, acted morally and as good members of society. Their understanding may not have been good, but their lives were fulfilling.
Now, however, we can see far more of the truth. We know infinitely more than the people centuries ago did, leading us to believe that God does not control everything. Many people have stopped holding that fear of God, many have chosen to drop out of the society as a result, and in many cases, morality seems to have taken the back burner to other issues. Yes, our understanding of science is greater, and we see far more of the truth, but we need to ask ourselves: is the societal damage worth it?
This is simply an offshoot that we can think about analyzing based off the dialectic between truth and perception in The Matrix. While The Matrix is not the be-all-end-all, it nonetheless presents a very important dialogue that we should have to make our lives as fulfilling as possible.
Sunday, April 29, 2012
Metacognition: Jane Eyre Mashup
When I started this project, I thought that it was just going to be some stupid English project that I could probably just fake my way through and be okay. I thought it was going to be really easy. I thought the limited time we had to work on this would make it very difficult to get it done well. I thought I was going to hate it.
Fortunately, I was wrong.
One of the first things that really surprised me about the dynamics of my mind was how much it seemed to love the extremely difficult challenge this project sometimes presented. Now, before I go on, I should probably explain myself a little bit. Yes, as I have said before, I love a good challenge, but only when it either involves logic, science, or is a fairly easy challenge.
The challenges this project would present seemed like neither to my disgruntled and already stressed mind. Nonetheless, it had to be done, so I groaned inwardly and started working. Much to my surprise, my mind seemed to become much less stressed and confused after I started working on that project than it had felt before. I actually started enjoying the challenge I had dreaded less than two hours before!
By the end of the project, my mind enjoyeed almost every part of this project and its challenge, which surprised me. However, that wasn't the really surprising bit. The surprising bit was the last really big challenge of the project: the works cited section.
Now, normally, bizarre as it may sound, my mind is the perfect kind of mind that's crazy/stupid enough to actually enjoy doing the works cited page. I normally love being able to look back through the sources we amassed over the course of the project and just feel some pride at how much work I/we've done. I loved how logical and formulaic the citations were; all you had to do was plug a few words into a formula, evaluate said formula, and stick it in a project.
This time though, I was so bored by it that I wanted to jump out the window, dig a little burrow, and hide from it. It wasn't just boring- it was absolutely mind-numbing. After spending several days doing the extremely difficult intellectual challenge of a postmodern exercise, I could not handle the simple, logical activity of a works cited page.
What surprised me most about this was that I found that my mind was not infinitely flexible- it could easily adapt to a new type of thinking and learn to really love it, but it could not snap right back to its old ways immediately. It would take time, as I learned the brutally hard way with that works cited section.
To my further surprise, this new understanding of how my mind works didn't scare me or depress me. In fact, it actually made me happier. There is something inherently comforting in knowing the limits of one's mind. You don't have to constantly wonder whether you pushed too far and missed the endpoint, to use a titration analogy. You now know where you have to keep pushing to extend the limits a bit more.
Finally, I saw tha my mind really does work much better under the pressure of a deadline. Granted, I try to get a lot of work done regardless, but I found especially clearly with this project that when there is not time to waste, my mind clicks up the concentration another notch and gets ready to do a lot of work in very little time. Unfortunately, this leads to more stress, but my mind also manages to push all of that aside until the work is all done, the project is turned in, and it's time to relax.
In short, if this project showed me one thing about the dynamics of my mind, it's that it is very adaptable and can adjust to its surroundings well. In the future, I would like to push the flexibility of my mind a little bit more, but at least for now, I find that I am sufficiently satisfied with how my mind changes and adapts to changing surroundings.
Fortunately, I was wrong.
One of the first things that really surprised me about the dynamics of my mind was how much it seemed to love the extremely difficult challenge this project sometimes presented. Now, before I go on, I should probably explain myself a little bit. Yes, as I have said before, I love a good challenge, but only when it either involves logic, science, or is a fairly easy challenge.
The challenges this project would present seemed like neither to my disgruntled and already stressed mind. Nonetheless, it had to be done, so I groaned inwardly and started working. Much to my surprise, my mind seemed to become much less stressed and confused after I started working on that project than it had felt before. I actually started enjoying the challenge I had dreaded less than two hours before!
By the end of the project, my mind enjoyeed almost every part of this project and its challenge, which surprised me. However, that wasn't the really surprising bit. The surprising bit was the last really big challenge of the project: the works cited section.
Now, normally, bizarre as it may sound, my mind is the perfect kind of mind that's crazy/stupid enough to actually enjoy doing the works cited page. I normally love being able to look back through the sources we amassed over the course of the project and just feel some pride at how much work I/we've done. I loved how logical and formulaic the citations were; all you had to do was plug a few words into a formula, evaluate said formula, and stick it in a project.
This time though, I was so bored by it that I wanted to jump out the window, dig a little burrow, and hide from it. It wasn't just boring- it was absolutely mind-numbing. After spending several days doing the extremely difficult intellectual challenge of a postmodern exercise, I could not handle the simple, logical activity of a works cited page.
What surprised me most about this was that I found that my mind was not infinitely flexible- it could easily adapt to a new type of thinking and learn to really love it, but it could not snap right back to its old ways immediately. It would take time, as I learned the brutally hard way with that works cited section.
To my further surprise, this new understanding of how my mind works didn't scare me or depress me. In fact, it actually made me happier. There is something inherently comforting in knowing the limits of one's mind. You don't have to constantly wonder whether you pushed too far and missed the endpoint, to use a titration analogy. You now know where you have to keep pushing to extend the limits a bit more.
Finally, I saw tha my mind really does work much better under the pressure of a deadline. Granted, I try to get a lot of work done regardless, but I found especially clearly with this project that when there is not time to waste, my mind clicks up the concentration another notch and gets ready to do a lot of work in very little time. Unfortunately, this leads to more stress, but my mind also manages to push all of that aside until the work is all done, the project is turned in, and it's time to relax.
In short, if this project showed me one thing about the dynamics of my mind, it's that it is very adaptable and can adjust to its surroundings well. In the future, I would like to push the flexibility of my mind a little bit more, but at least for now, I find that I am sufficiently satisfied with how my mind changes and adapts to changing surroundings.
Friday, April 6, 2012
My Thoughts on the Play
I absolutely loved CST's rendition of A Midsummer Night's Dream.
Before watching this play, the only Shakespeare I had read or seen were tragedies, so I didn't know what to expect when watching one of his comedies. I was half expecting all the characters to start dropping dead regardless, so it was with a mixture of apprehension and excitement that I sat down to watch.
Right from the very beginning, I knew this play was going to be nothing like Lear or Macbeth. As I continued watching, I found that it was as funny and entertaining as anything I've ever seen. And, of course, it was a major bonus that nobody died.
One of the things that surprised me about how I approached the play was how little I seemed to care about the oldness of Shakespeare's language. It might have simply been because I had seen and managed to understand Macbeth earlier, or because I had read some other Shakespeare works and understood those earlier, or possibly just because I thought I'd be able to just read the acting and get the plot, even without understanding the words.
It was thus a very pleasant surprise when I found that right from the beginning, it wasn't just possible to understand the language, it was positively easy! Maybe that's because I've had some exposure to the language before, but whatever the reason was, it certainly made the play much more enjoyable.
I was also very happy that I managed to actually pay attention for almost the entire play. Normally, I have a bit of trouble focusing for long periods of time on one thing, and I generally either drift off for a minute of two or I have to try very hard to concentrate.
However, during this play (which, for this purpose, I consider a very long period of time), I could count on one hand how many times I zone out, and a few fingers still wouldn't be up. I think it's far more likely that this was because of the wonderful acting, engaging plot line, and hilarious dialogue than to me discovering new powers of concentration.
This play has and definitely will continue to affect how I approach Shakespeare. I am very happy I had the chance to see it.
Before watching this play, the only Shakespeare I had read or seen were tragedies, so I didn't know what to expect when watching one of his comedies. I was half expecting all the characters to start dropping dead regardless, so it was with a mixture of apprehension and excitement that I sat down to watch.
Right from the very beginning, I knew this play was going to be nothing like Lear or Macbeth. As I continued watching, I found that it was as funny and entertaining as anything I've ever seen. And, of course, it was a major bonus that nobody died.
One of the things that surprised me about how I approached the play was how little I seemed to care about the oldness of Shakespeare's language. It might have simply been because I had seen and managed to understand Macbeth earlier, or because I had read some other Shakespeare works and understood those earlier, or possibly just because I thought I'd be able to just read the acting and get the plot, even without understanding the words.
It was thus a very pleasant surprise when I found that right from the beginning, it wasn't just possible to understand the language, it was positively easy! Maybe that's because I've had some exposure to the language before, but whatever the reason was, it certainly made the play much more enjoyable.
I was also very happy that I managed to actually pay attention for almost the entire play. Normally, I have a bit of trouble focusing for long periods of time on one thing, and I generally either drift off for a minute of two or I have to try very hard to concentrate.
However, during this play (which, for this purpose, I consider a very long period of time), I could count on one hand how many times I zone out, and a few fingers still wouldn't be up. I think it's far more likely that this was because of the wonderful acting, engaging plot line, and hilarious dialogue than to me discovering new powers of concentration.
This play has and definitely will continue to affect how I approach Shakespeare. I am very happy I had the chance to see it.
Thursday, March 22, 2012
Metacognition: My Short Story
While going through the various drafts of my short story, I started noticing some things about how I was thinking and how I was approaching the problem ahead of me that I didn't expect to see, least of all when I was just writing some random assignment for English.
I started out this assignment as I always do for writing assignments: dismayed, unhappy, lethargic, resigned to my fate. I really did not want to write that story. It was a Friday night, and I had a lot of work to do for math team, but I hate procrastinating, so I grudgingly decided to start doing it.
By the time my allotment of 300 words was done, I was craving more. I soon got it in the form of steps 2-5, and it was during that time that I noticed the most change in how I thought not only about the assignment and how to do it, but also how I thought through problems and attacked them.
Firstly, I was somewhat surprised about how I ended up thinking about the assignment. I had started off thinking that it was just a dull waste of time, and that I just wanted to get it out of the way as fast as I possibly could. However, very quickly, I was thinking it was great fun. I was enthralled by the project, to the point where I even ignored distractions I normally give in to, like my good friend D**** chatting me on Gmail.
This may sound like I'm just talking generically about writing in general, and to some degree, I am, but I never have quite this much fun writing. For all the other writing assignments, I would be able to tolerate the writing and ignore some distractions, but never have fun. This one was different. In this writing assignment, my mind simply locked onto the task and had as much fun as possible with it.
It was during this phase of the story writing that I discovered how much I like telling a story. Of course, I knew before that I liked relating anecdotes to others, but this wasn't just relating some brief anecdote, it was creating a whole new place which I hoped to have people fall into. I learned during this assignment that my mind loves having the ability to create a new structure, a new world of fiction.
Of course, the process of writing my story wasn't all fun. A lot of it was overcoming massive problems with the plot and trying to get my story to resonate on multiple levels, not just a superficial one. However, not only did attacking these problems make my story much better, it forced my mind to do things that are far different from what they normally do.
One example of this happened when I was trying to figure out what to get my character to do at a certain point in my story. At first, I thought about the problem as I try to think about most things: as a detached observer. I started trying to play god with my character, manipulating his world however I saw fit, doing whatever I wanted to do with him.
I got absolutely nowhere.
I struggled with this for a bit, and unconciously, my mind started thinking about my character in first person. I started asking not what my character should do next, but what I should do next. Suddenly, it was very personal, and I knew exactly what to do with my character. I ended up overcoming that particular hurdle and making that part of my story much richer and deeper than it had previously been.
I discovered at that moment that my mind not only can take steps on its own to attack creative problems, but that it has the ability to empathize with others to overcome problems, even though it chooses not to do so in most cases.
Both of these lessons surprised me for various reasons. I've always thought of my mind as being very rational and fact-oriented. In fact, I've prided myself on that. To realize suddenly that my mind actually has a very, very, very significant story-telling, emotional side is not only surprising, it's intriguing. It makes me want to learn even more about how my mind works so I can best make use of it.
In particular, I like realizing that my mind has the ability to almost unconciously take action to solve problems with emotions and empathy when rationality fails. I am very pleased about that. I would be very pleased if I was able to improve my story telling, as I feel it would help my mind grasp concepts from all topics and subjects if I was able to relate the concept to myself as a story, because I find I learn better if I do that.
I never expected all these insights and discoveries to come from just one writing assignment. It's good to see how wrong I am sometimes.
I started out this assignment as I always do for writing assignments: dismayed, unhappy, lethargic, resigned to my fate. I really did not want to write that story. It was a Friday night, and I had a lot of work to do for math team, but I hate procrastinating, so I grudgingly decided to start doing it.
By the time my allotment of 300 words was done, I was craving more. I soon got it in the form of steps 2-5, and it was during that time that I noticed the most change in how I thought not only about the assignment and how to do it, but also how I thought through problems and attacked them.
Firstly, I was somewhat surprised about how I ended up thinking about the assignment. I had started off thinking that it was just a dull waste of time, and that I just wanted to get it out of the way as fast as I possibly could. However, very quickly, I was thinking it was great fun. I was enthralled by the project, to the point where I even ignored distractions I normally give in to, like my good friend D**** chatting me on Gmail.
This may sound like I'm just talking generically about writing in general, and to some degree, I am, but I never have quite this much fun writing. For all the other writing assignments, I would be able to tolerate the writing and ignore some distractions, but never have fun. This one was different. In this writing assignment, my mind simply locked onto the task and had as much fun as possible with it.
It was during this phase of the story writing that I discovered how much I like telling a story. Of course, I knew before that I liked relating anecdotes to others, but this wasn't just relating some brief anecdote, it was creating a whole new place which I hoped to have people fall into. I learned during this assignment that my mind loves having the ability to create a new structure, a new world of fiction.
Of course, the process of writing my story wasn't all fun. A lot of it was overcoming massive problems with the plot and trying to get my story to resonate on multiple levels, not just a superficial one. However, not only did attacking these problems make my story much better, it forced my mind to do things that are far different from what they normally do.
One example of this happened when I was trying to figure out what to get my character to do at a certain point in my story. At first, I thought about the problem as I try to think about most things: as a detached observer. I started trying to play god with my character, manipulating his world however I saw fit, doing whatever I wanted to do with him.
I got absolutely nowhere.
I struggled with this for a bit, and unconciously, my mind started thinking about my character in first person. I started asking not what my character should do next, but what I should do next. Suddenly, it was very personal, and I knew exactly what to do with my character. I ended up overcoming that particular hurdle and making that part of my story much richer and deeper than it had previously been.
I discovered at that moment that my mind not only can take steps on its own to attack creative problems, but that it has the ability to empathize with others to overcome problems, even though it chooses not to do so in most cases.
Both of these lessons surprised me for various reasons. I've always thought of my mind as being very rational and fact-oriented. In fact, I've prided myself on that. To realize suddenly that my mind actually has a very, very, very significant story-telling, emotional side is not only surprising, it's intriguing. It makes me want to learn even more about how my mind works so I can best make use of it.
In particular, I like realizing that my mind has the ability to almost unconciously take action to solve problems with emotions and empathy when rationality fails. I am very pleased about that. I would be very pleased if I was able to improve my story telling, as I feel it would help my mind grasp concepts from all topics and subjects if I was able to relate the concept to myself as a story, because I find I learn better if I do that.
I never expected all these insights and discoveries to come from just one writing assignment. It's good to see how wrong I am sometimes.
Friday, March 9, 2012
Inconvenient Truth: Humans are Hollow
One of the main things about Heart of Darkness that I really hated was the conept Conrad brought up about humans really being hollow, wild, and savage at the core. We saw this in Marlow's description of Kurtz, when Marlow described this elegant, intelligent, charismatic, classic European man. He described how he had written this beautiful paper on surpressing savage customs back in Europe. And at the very end of the whole paper, he scrawled his true desire: to exterminate them all.
Later, down in the Congo, when Marlow and Kurtz encounter each other on the trail, Marlow notices that Kurtz's hollow core had been filled with its original and natural instincts- the wild spell of the wilderness. He notices that Kurtz was still brilliant, still intelligent, but had reverted to his natural state, a hollow, savage beast. He notices that as Kurtz is withdrawn from the wild, he is withdrawn from himself, and he dies.
I really don't want to accept what this is saying about human nature.
One of the things that this implies is that even the best and the brightest among us can really be nothing more than thin veneers, covering up something far worse, something far more horrible and savage. These people, these highly intelligent, successful people are my role models; they are the people I look up to and try to emulate. Had I been a European during that time period, I'm sure I would have been looking up to Kurtz as an intellectual role model just like everyone else.
For that reason, I find it absolutely infuriating to think that these wonderful people, supposedly the best of our society, are really no more than nicely covered beasts. If they are, then that leaves two possibilities. In one scenario, it means that these people that I, along with many others, look up to are really not the best, but in fact, some of the worst of our societies. Clearly, that is something I don't want to believe.
But the thing that scares me even more is the thought that maybe that conclustion is incorrect.
Maybe they really are the best in our society.
If so, that paints a picture which I feel is at the very root of what I really hate about this theory Heart of Darkness raises. What that scenario is saying is that despite how horrible these bright people really are at the core, compared to the rest of the our race, they still are the best. The rest of the race is even more savage, even more brutal, even more horrible than the Kurtzes. After all, literally everyone but Marlow was absolutely fine with what they were seeing and doing in the Congo.
Marlow brings up a good point, though. One way I can help myself come to terms with this horrible theory is by remembering what Marlow's story tells us about him and people like him. Despite not being the very best in Europe, despite just being another adventurous grunt in the middle of the jungle, despite the fact that he saw everything that the others saw in the Congo, Marlow came out of there changed, but not savage. He showed restraint. The cannibals, the alleged savages in the jungle, showed restraint.
What they tell me is that this is not necessarily a universal problem. It tells me that it is far more likely that the first scenario, and not the second, is true. It shows me that, despite how dark humans can get, there are still some people who manage to, even in the worst situations, retain some humanity.
Later, down in the Congo, when Marlow and Kurtz encounter each other on the trail, Marlow notices that Kurtz's hollow core had been filled with its original and natural instincts- the wild spell of the wilderness. He notices that Kurtz was still brilliant, still intelligent, but had reverted to his natural state, a hollow, savage beast. He notices that as Kurtz is withdrawn from the wild, he is withdrawn from himself, and he dies.
I really don't want to accept what this is saying about human nature.
One of the things that this implies is that even the best and the brightest among us can really be nothing more than thin veneers, covering up something far worse, something far more horrible and savage. These people, these highly intelligent, successful people are my role models; they are the people I look up to and try to emulate. Had I been a European during that time period, I'm sure I would have been looking up to Kurtz as an intellectual role model just like everyone else.
For that reason, I find it absolutely infuriating to think that these wonderful people, supposedly the best of our society, are really no more than nicely covered beasts. If they are, then that leaves two possibilities. In one scenario, it means that these people that I, along with many others, look up to are really not the best, but in fact, some of the worst of our societies. Clearly, that is something I don't want to believe.
But the thing that scares me even more is the thought that maybe that conclustion is incorrect.
Maybe they really are the best in our society.
If so, that paints a picture which I feel is at the very root of what I really hate about this theory Heart of Darkness raises. What that scenario is saying is that despite how horrible these bright people really are at the core, compared to the rest of the our race, they still are the best. The rest of the race is even more savage, even more brutal, even more horrible than the Kurtzes. After all, literally everyone but Marlow was absolutely fine with what they were seeing and doing in the Congo.
Marlow brings up a good point, though. One way I can help myself come to terms with this horrible theory is by remembering what Marlow's story tells us about him and people like him. Despite not being the very best in Europe, despite just being another adventurous grunt in the middle of the jungle, despite the fact that he saw everything that the others saw in the Congo, Marlow came out of there changed, but not savage. He showed restraint. The cannibals, the alleged savages in the jungle, showed restraint.
What they tell me is that this is not necessarily a universal problem. It tells me that it is far more likely that the first scenario, and not the second, is true. It shows me that, despite how dark humans can get, there are still some people who manage to, even in the worst situations, retain some humanity.
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Captured Thought: Human Nature
As usual, I was sitting in my nice, comfy chair in my room, trying to focus on Heart of Darkness. Unfortunately, as usual, my mind kept drifting away.
This time, it had been a really long day, and I was tired, and my back hurt, and my head hurt, and I wanted to go to sleep, and Conrad had such a boring writing style; the list of whines and completely legitimate excuses for not doing my best while reading that section just went on and on. Nonetheless, being the trooper that I am, I powered through the whole section, understanding everything I read and completely ignoring the parts that I didn't.
Shortly thereafter, I realized I had just ignored 4 straight pages. Annoyed, I started over.
This time, for some reason or the other, I actually understood most of what I read, with the exception of just a few sections (I never said I was perfect). Sadly, one of those sections happened to be one of the most famous in literature, when Kurtz screams "the horror! The horror!"
Actually, I understood quite a bit about that section. I understood that Kurtz was on his deathbed, and that those were essentially his last words. I knew that Marlow had some intensely deep thoughts about those words. I know that Marlow later lied to Kurtz's intended about what his last words, presumably to make her feel better. Really, the section was pretty open-and-shut. The only bit that I was missing was what any of it was supposed to mean. It seemed to be a comment on life, but, what exactly was it saying?
Ehh, who cares? I wonder what's for dinner...
Of course, if I had been a bit brighter, I would have realized that this was sure to come up during dicussions, but I wasn't, so I was in for a very unpleasant shock when I saw it was on the question list. So, as usual, while everyone else was busy coming up with magnificent insights about what Kurtz meant when he said "the horror," I was sitting in my desk like a sack of beans, trying to "absorb the information."
As the discussion progressed, I felt as if I could partially understand what was going on, but I didn't really get the implication behind the statement. Who cares if Africa is a place where all the horrors of the human psyche come out? First of all, that's racist, and second, I'm not planning on colonizing the Congo any time soon.
Shortly thereafter, we moved on to Kurtz's intended, and then, finally, why Marlow lied to her. At that point, I heard D---- gasp dramatically and shoot his hand into the air. Mr. A**** saw this too, and called on him. D---- then informed us that in this section, Marlow was really referring to how all of Europe was also the horror, and at that point, my mind just completely left the room to shoot off in its own direction.
I started thinking about how that line must not have been intended just as a comment on Africa, but on the whole world instead. One of the big things about Kurtz's expedition was that he was pushed too far, cracked, and allowed his more savage, dark, horrible instincts take over, which society had been surpressing. But if that comment referred to Europe and the rest of the civilized world, then that would mean that the very act of surpression created another horror, one of ignorance, one of a very dark human nature. In short, at that moment, 2 days worth of information-absorbing, reading, and thinking all clicked together to tell me that this was telling us to watch out from ourselves, because human nature is dark and just a moment from snapping.
I looked over at D----. I wasn't sure whether to hug him for serving as a catalyst for that realization or to punch him for depressing me. I compromised by giving him a really pathetic high-five.
This time, it had been a really long day, and I was tired, and my back hurt, and my head hurt, and I wanted to go to sleep, and Conrad had such a boring writing style; the list of whines and completely legitimate excuses for not doing my best while reading that section just went on and on. Nonetheless, being the trooper that I am, I powered through the whole section, understanding everything I read and completely ignoring the parts that I didn't.
Shortly thereafter, I realized I had just ignored 4 straight pages. Annoyed, I started over.
This time, for some reason or the other, I actually understood most of what I read, with the exception of just a few sections (I never said I was perfect). Sadly, one of those sections happened to be one of the most famous in literature, when Kurtz screams "the horror! The horror!"
Actually, I understood quite a bit about that section. I understood that Kurtz was on his deathbed, and that those were essentially his last words. I knew that Marlow had some intensely deep thoughts about those words. I know that Marlow later lied to Kurtz's intended about what his last words, presumably to make her feel better. Really, the section was pretty open-and-shut. The only bit that I was missing was what any of it was supposed to mean. It seemed to be a comment on life, but, what exactly was it saying?
Ehh, who cares? I wonder what's for dinner...
Of course, if I had been a bit brighter, I would have realized that this was sure to come up during dicussions, but I wasn't, so I was in for a very unpleasant shock when I saw it was on the question list. So, as usual, while everyone else was busy coming up with magnificent insights about what Kurtz meant when he said "the horror," I was sitting in my desk like a sack of beans, trying to "absorb the information."
As the discussion progressed, I felt as if I could partially understand what was going on, but I didn't really get the implication behind the statement. Who cares if Africa is a place where all the horrors of the human psyche come out? First of all, that's racist, and second, I'm not planning on colonizing the Congo any time soon.
Shortly thereafter, we moved on to Kurtz's intended, and then, finally, why Marlow lied to her. At that point, I heard D---- gasp dramatically and shoot his hand into the air. Mr. A**** saw this too, and called on him. D---- then informed us that in this section, Marlow was really referring to how all of Europe was also the horror, and at that point, my mind just completely left the room to shoot off in its own direction.
I started thinking about how that line must not have been intended just as a comment on Africa, but on the whole world instead. One of the big things about Kurtz's expedition was that he was pushed too far, cracked, and allowed his more savage, dark, horrible instincts take over, which society had been surpressing. But if that comment referred to Europe and the rest of the civilized world, then that would mean that the very act of surpression created another horror, one of ignorance, one of a very dark human nature. In short, at that moment, 2 days worth of information-absorbing, reading, and thinking all clicked together to tell me that this was telling us to watch out from ourselves, because human nature is dark and just a moment from snapping.
I looked over at D----. I wasn't sure whether to hug him for serving as a catalyst for that realization or to punch him for depressing me. I compromised by giving him a really pathetic high-five.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
One of the problems we run into when we try to analyze this is whether freedom is having total control over our lives or having the ability to make some choices of how our lives are run. I think that freedom would be the latter, with the former being described as autonomy.
Autonomy would not only be far more difficult to attain, but, as you mentioned in your blog entry, it would be a far more austere and difficult life than one without autonomy, but with freedom. In a way, the Matrix thus relates to a work we read by John Donne last year, in which he says that "No man is an island."
Everybody does have some connection to the rest of the world that is necessary for their way of life, and it cannot be easily shed. However, that does not make it bad. One can argue that civilization is simply the act of giving up autonomy for a much more pleasant lifestyle.
Even the Matrix alludes to this when Neo doesn't respond ot Morpheus asking "Even if you could go back, would you?"
Very nicely done, Nina.
Comment on Daniel Ahn's "Dialectics: Empiricism and Rationalism"
Summary: In this post, Daniel explored the relationship between empiricism and rationalism in the Matrix, focusing greatly on how it impacted definitions of reality. He said that the difference in views occured when the empiricist would say the Matrix is real and the rationalist would say it is a lie.
My Comment: Daniel, this was a great entry. It really got me to think about what we define to be real and to think about the philosophies we learned both in history and in english.
This seems to relate greatly to the brain-in-the-vat thought experiment. The brain-in-the-vat was a thought expiriment in which a brain was placed inside a vat of life-sustaining fluids and fed electrical signals simulating the act of actually living. The brain would think that it is seeing, feeling, creating, and living just as a normal human being would. However, it technically isn't- it's simply a blob of cells being fed electricity in a jar.
Of course, this not only raises the philosophical conundrum of what we define as real, it also raises the question of which is more important.
In the end, at least on an individual level, does it matter to the brain that it isn't actually living the life it thinks it does? Of course not. It treats those thoughts as its reality, complete with choices, happiness, sadness, and everything else you can imagine. The fact that it lives in the vat makes no difference to it. The reality that the brain sees is much more important than the actuality that the brain lives in.
Very nice post, Daniel.