Friday, May 11, 2012

Blogging Around

Comment on Nina's "Dialectics: Systems and Freedom"

Summary: In this blog, Nina analyzes the dynamics between being in the system of the Matrix and being liberated from it. She notes that while one may have absolute control over their own lives outside of the Matrix, it would appear to be a much happier and easier life within the Matrix, with much less hardship and many more choices than the "real world."

My Comment: Nina, this was a very well written, thought-provoking blog entry. I really enjoyed reading this.

One of the things that struck me about this essay is how much it seemed to relate to one of Jacob L's posts from a while back regarding determinism and free will. Both of them seemed to deal with the same issue of whether or not we actually have freedom to choose our own path in life. I personally believe there is a distinction to be made.

One of the problems we run into when we try to analyze this is whether freedom is having total control over our lives or having the ability to make some choices of how our lives are run. I think that freedom would be the latter, with the former being described as autonomy.

Autonomy would not only be far more difficult to attain, but, as you mentioned in your blog entry, it would be a far more austere and difficult life than one without autonomy, but with freedom. In a way, the Matrix thus relates to a work we read by John Donne last year, in which he says that "No man is an island."

Everybody does have some connection to the rest of the world that is necessary for their way of life, and it cannot be easily shed. However, that does not make it bad. One can argue that civilization is simply the act of giving up autonomy for a much more pleasant lifestyle.

Even the Matrix alludes to this when Neo doesn't respond ot Morpheus asking "Even if you could go back, would you?"

Very nicely done, Nina.

Comment on Daniel Ahn's "Dialectics: Empiricism and Rationalism"

Summary: In this post, Daniel explored the relationship between empiricism and rationalism in the Matrix, focusing greatly on how it impacted definitions of reality. He said that the difference in views occured when the empiricist would say the Matrix is real and the rationalist would say it is a lie.

My Comment: Daniel, this was a great entry. It really got me to think about what we define to be real and to think about the philosophies we learned both in history and in english.

This seems to relate greatly to the brain-in-the-vat thought experiment. The brain-in-the-vat was a thought expiriment in which a brain was placed inside a vat of life-sustaining fluids and fed electrical signals simulating the act of actually living. The brain would think that it is seeing, feeling, creating, and living just as a normal human being would. However, it technically isn't- it's simply a blob of cells being fed electricity in a jar.

Of course, this not only raises the philosophical conundrum of what we define as real, it also raises the question of which is more important.

In the end, at least on an individual level, does it matter to the brain that it isn't actually living the life it thinks it does? Of course not. It treats those thoughts as its reality, complete with choices, happiness, sadness, and everything else you can imagine. The fact that it lives in the vat makes no difference to it. The reality that the brain sees is much more important than the actuality that the brain lives in.

Very nice post, Daniel.

Sunday, May 6, 2012

Dialectics: Truth and Perception

Over the course of The Matrix, there was a very interesting dialectic introduced between truth and perception. The dialectic seems to focus mostly on which is more important and more fulfilling, with different arguments being raised by everyone from Neo to Agent Smith, from Morpheus to Cipher.

Arguing on the side of truth being more important were Morpheus and Neo. Their primary argument for truth being superior to perception was simply that perception is a tool to keep us enslaved, and the truth is the only thing that can set us free.

Over the course of the movie, though there are problems with learning the truth, such as constant danger, discomforting knowledge, and physical privations, there was still a very strong case being made for the truth to be more important. Not only did it free one from the control of the machines, but it also freed them from the rules.

To Morpheus and Neo, that was probably the most important. With the truth, they were able to see through the normal rules of the Matrix and to essentially do whatever they wanted. They could fly, they could learn at a moment's notice, they could be lightning-fast and impossibly strong. They could doge bullets or take seven shots at point-blank range and still get up, all because the truth freed them from the rules.

To everyone in the movie who chose the truth over perception, they saw both the good and the bad of the world, and they chose to focus on the good that came out of their decision. However, there were several characters in the movie who chose to focus on the bad side of learning the truth, primarily Cipher and Agent Smith.

To them, the truth was not nearly as important as what the perception of the truth was, their argument being that it doesn't matter if you are enslaved, so long as you are a happy slave.

We saw this in especially sharp relief when Cipher was in a secret meeting with Agent Smith, talking about how he wanted to go back into the Matrix, saying that he realized after his time on the bleak, privation-filled ship that "ignorance is bliss." He doesn't care that he will have to follow the rules like everyone else. He just sees that those who see the truth are dissatisfied, and he chooses to go back to only seeing perception and becoming satisfied once more.

In the end, the Matrix seems to agree with John Stuart Mills, saying that it is better to see the unsatisfactory truth than to be a perception-filled pig satisfied. This dialectic opened by The Matrix, however, has many other practical applications aw well.

For example, this can throw into question whether or not scientific progress is really all that great after all. Centuries ago, the perception of the world around us was that God controlled everything, and you had to be good for the world around us to be good. People believed that. People dedicated their lives to that. People held a fear of God, and they, for the most part, acted morally and as good members of society. Their understanding may not have been good, but their lives were fulfilling.

Now, however, we can see far more of the truth. We know infinitely more than the people centuries ago did, leading us to believe that God does not control everything. Many people have stopped holding that fear of God, many have chosen to drop out of the society as a result, and in many cases, morality seems to have taken the back burner to other issues. Yes, our understanding of science is greater, and we see far more of the truth, but we need to ask ourselves: is the societal damage worth it?

This is simply an offshoot that we can think about analyzing based off the dialectic between truth and perception in The Matrix. While The Matrix is not the be-all-end-all, it nonetheless presents a very important dialogue that we should have to make our lives as fulfilling as possible.