Monday, November 7, 2011

Blogging Around

For some reason or the other, the comment tool was not working on my computer, so I've only posted my comments on other people's blogs here.

On Derek Choi's entry titled "An Inconvenient Truth: Compassion Fatigue:"

Summary: Despite the fact that we feel the need to help the victims of some disaster as soon as it happens and begin pouring out our hearts (and our pocketbooks) to them, as soon as they are out of sight (i.e. the media leaves), those victims are also out of mind.

My comment: This was a very nicely written post on an unfortunate fact of today's society, and unfortunately, it does not seem like there is very much that we can do to stop this. First of all, there is the massive and all-mighty media, which literally controls our knowledge- the "free" country's version of Big Brother, which censors for the sake of profits. Now, especially with the illusion that we can have anything we want at our fingertips with the advent of the internet, the media needs to become increasingly sensationalist in order to survive and to grasp the average person's attention for more than 20 seconds.

Unfortunately, people get bored. Very easily, in fact, so as a result, the media has to be able to not dwell on a topic for too long. However, as soon as they leave a disaster in favor of another story, subconciously, people begin to think that the disaster is not as important as this new story, so they just put it out of their mind. And sadly, unless we take down essentially all of the modern world, there isn't much we can do to stop the masses from acting this way.

However, that isn't to say that we can't do something. We can attempt to change our behavior to avoid conforming to this compassion fatigue. I hold no impressions that doing so will help stop the masses from experiencing this, but I suppose every little bit that you can do will help a little bit.

Regardless, this was a very nice post.


On Jacob Levin's post titled "An Inconvenient Truth: Determinism"

Summary: Despite all of the logical explanations for the theory of determinism, in which given certain conditions, everything that happens is the only possible outcome, other, better supported arguments against this and for free will can be made, thus leading to the conclusion that determinism does not exist.

My comment: First of all, I would like to commend you on your use of humor throughout this post. I must admit that I was a bit daunted by the title, but I read the first few lines, and decided that the post couldn't be all too bad, so I kept reading.

I completely agree with the idea that determinism doesn't hold practical water, but I'm also not quite sure what you mean by free will in the context of quantum theory. To use your example of you showing up naked to school tomorrow, isn't that happening on some other plane of reality? If that is the case, as quantum theory states, then you would be both showing up clothed and naked at once. In short, you would be condemned to do everything and nothing at the same time. To me, that isn't free will. Free will to me is not just having the ability to make the choices that you want, but also to have the ability to make choices to not do something, and even with the quantum theory, we do not have that ability.

Granted, you could say that those choices are not being made on the "main" universe, but how do you define "main?" Each of those universes is the "main" universe to their inhabitants, so we can't really say that any of those choices are part of the "main" universe. In short, because we cannot avoid making a certain choice, we do not have the free will to stop that, and thus, free will does not exist.
I'm going to have to wrap this up before I end up confusing myself even more. Regardless of my opinion on free will, I still think you did a very nice job stating your case and exploring that topic.

No comments:

Post a Comment