One of the biggest arguments that always seems to take place in Washington is over the all-important issue of taxes, and whether or not to impose them on the wealthiest Americans. As a fiscal conservative, I was naturally inclined to say that taxes should be decreased on the upper class, but whenever I would hear the idea of taxes being raised on the rich, for some reason, I would just get absolutely infuriated. It wasn't the style of argumentation that was annoying me. As far as that went, the argument was perfect. There was just something in that theory that taxes should be raised because trickle-down economics doesn't work that made me want to tear something to shreds. The real question, of course, is "why?" Why would a political argument like that anger me like none other can?
One of the big implications of this truth that I struggle with simply understanding is the fact that this is essentially punishing the wealthy for their hard work. Granted, I will acknowledge that less fortunate people do also work just as hard, but if that is truly the case, then shouldn't everyone pay the same tax rate? The biggest implication in this argument, then, is that most of those rich people are just undeserving little rats that make their living off exploiting the little people.
Now that I think about it, this seems to be the part that angers me the most. One can become cynical enough to expect unfairness such as the one being presented by punishing the rich for their hard work, but a broad generalization like that really angers me. When you say that all rich people are undeserving, you lump into that generalization people like Bill Gates or Warren Buffett or the late Steve Jobs, people who were intelligent enough to innovate new technologies or ideas and greatly improve the entire world through their efforts. By saying that the rich should have to pay higher tax rates than the poor because the rich are less deserving, one is essentially denying credit to the people who have changed the world, and that is something that is so unfair, even I'm not cynical enough to let that pass.
But that really doesn't seem to account for all of the anger that I feel towards this stance. A major part of trickle-down economics is that it has worked in the past, most notably with Ronald Reagan in the Great Recession of the '80s, when, in no small part due to his tax rates, the country went from the absolute brink of collapse to prosperity.
Saying that this policy won't work now seems to imply that this time is different from the past, that we are in uncharted territory, and for someone who takes comfort in knowing that history repeats itself, that is not so much angering as extremely worrysome, which adds to the angry/negative feeling that this concept gives me.
So now that I have identified the problem, what are some things I can do to address this?
Well, for starters, I can begin to try to remember that when most people are talking about the undeserving rich, they are talking about the embezzlers and are merely ignorant of the truth. As for the whole uncharted waters problem, I can just try to remember that, often times, history has told us tha tthe greatest treasures lay on the otehr side of the vast unknown territories. I can't say that this will make me change my stance- it won't. However, it hopefully will help me become less angry and uneasy at the concept of trickle-down economics not working.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI, too, am a fiscal conservative, but I’d like to play devil’s advocate for a moment (and according to the GOP spam emails I receive, I am advocating for the devil here). America is currently in a hole of 14-trillion-dollar proportions. We can cut and cut and cut and cut but that won’t get us out of that hole. Given that the U.S. federal annual budget is currently about 3.5 trillion dollars, we would have to slash 100% of government spending for four years to get back into the black. Obviously, cutting can’t be the only solution.
ReplyDeleteNor is anyone advocating the sort of drastic increases in taxes that Wall Street Journal editorials routinely decry. As Jon Stewart recently put it, “there is a huge battle going on in Washington between the Republicans who want to cut spending and the Democrats who want to cut spending and just raise taxes a little bit”. American tax rates for the highest tax bracket are the lowest they’ve ever been in decades. During the Great Depression, the highest tax bracket was set at 95% (although only one man, J.P. Morgan, qualified). Yes, we do need to curtail spending, but we also need to increase revenue.
Yes, if thou art making that argument, thou must be-eth the devil.
DeleteI agree. Of course we will need to raise taxes a little bit if we want dig ourselves out of this hole. But if you are pushing for fairness in taxes, why not just raise everyone's taxes by the same amount? What is so inherently unfair about that?
Secondly, while I do see some of the logic in Jon Stewart's comment, it is important to remember one thing. He is not a news man. He is a comedian. While it is fine to look at him for his comedic value, he has the same credibility as a nonpartisan news provider that Glenn Beck has. The battle in Washington could also be described as being between Republicans who want to slash spending and Democrats who want to cut spending a little bit and significantly raise taxes on just the rich. And if you were to look at the numbersm those statements would be equally accurate (or, more accurately, inaccurate).
An analogy I heard that I particularly liked was that the US is heading at 90 miles per hour towards a cliff. The Republican approach was to put the car into reverse and gun the engine the other way, whereas the Democrats' approach was to cut the speed to 60 miles per hour and try to drain the fuel from the tank (a pointless thing to do at that point and speed). Not entirely accurate, but not entirely inaccurate either.
It is also important to remember that the tax rate was 95% in *the Great Depression*.
However, there are other ways to increase revenue besides just raising taxes. First, simplify the tax code. Get rid of the loopholes that let the corporations and the super-wealthy hire fancy lawyers to avoid the taxes. The loopholes were put in by lobbyists, anyways.
Second, broaden the base by creating new jobs. If that means we need to lower taxes for a bit to try to fuel the economy, if it means we need to cut a bit more for now to offset those taxes, if it means a healthier economy, isn't it worth it?
Rohan -
ReplyDeleteI'd first like to tell you that had you not written a blog post about trickle-down economics, I soon may have [ranted about it], (so thank you for saving me anger and my keyboard bruises).
There are quite a few wealthy people in the United States. Not proportionally, of course, to the rest of the population, but the top 1%, as we all know, controls roughly 40% of the net GDP of the United States (I won't cite sources). The question arises - do these wealthy people work the hardest? Mitt Romney may be wealthy because he works hard. Millionaires and billionaires all over our country are wealthy because they work hard. But what constitutes 'working hard', and when are we 'punching the wealthy for their hard work', as you describe? If a lower-middle-class construction worker works just as 'hard', should be be punished?
The answer to this question is no, but as you point out, there's a catch. Those that are pro-tax hikes when it comes to wealthy Americans are constantly bombarded with arguments regarding, as you make so clear, the 'undeserving little rats that make their living off exploiting the little people'. We all know this is a false reality. Exploitation occurs, but not everyone who is rich has exploited others. There are many exemplary billionaires.
We arrive at the question - why are taxes low or stolid for the rich now? Because they are friendly with policymakers? Possibly. Yet that would be a grim ultimatum for a grimmer political system a small percentage of us still hold to be legitimate (that was a loaded sentence). We'd like to think it relates to political treatment of the concept of American class equality, and the cliché 'class warfare' battle. When we raise taxes for wealthy Americans - as you bring up, we raise taxes for the Bill Gates and Steve Jobs - those who are good for the universe and who change the world. What about those who have committed financial fraud (I plan to join the SEC)? They should have to pay, rather than the inventors, philanthropists, and brilliant ones. Yet we cannot, in today's political climate, be so fickle as to raise taxes for Mr. Blankfein [sic Bankfiend], but not Mr. Gates. That would be disastrous.
What is our final goal? To strengthen our economy? You bring up the Reagan golden years - times when taxes were low for those on top. If the question of whether to raise taxes on the rich were purely a political question, this debate might be over. Taxes might be higher or lower. Yet rhetoric, as you so clearly mention, enters the debate.
My anger stems from the same place yours does. Who are we stigmatizing? How are we going to equally distribute tax increases across our upper classes? By raising capital gains taxes? Because everyone who pays capital gains taxes must be wealthy. Everyone who pays luxury taxes must also be handsomely wealthy. Do I want my capital gains taxes to rise? No! It becomes a question of something more important - a crude term many don't, unfortunately, understand - obligation.
Unfortunately, according to a mutual friend, maestro Gauss, there is always going to be a small percentage of rich people, a larger percentage of middle class people, and a still smaller percentage of poorer people. The tables have turned today - the rich have pushed the middle class majority through the roof, secluding themselves in their section of the bell curve. This is in the numbers. As you touched on, there should be some examination, be it woefully biased, of the motive for raising taxes. Do we look to deprive the rich? No. A lack of liquidity is impairing governmental functioning. You describe this anger - this questioning - why must it come from the rich? If we are to further cut costs and impair middle class functioning, lack of some sort of governmental subsidy if bound to cut into incomes, creating an illusion of an economic downturn. The money is coalescing in one place. To save the economy the wealthy depend on, it should be in their best interests to contribute our country's various trusts (under the assumption action is taken on their efficiencies).
Delete'But what about the big government?' so many of us ask. Many are angry. The argument is fair. Will tax revenues fuel an ever growing governmental system of subsidy to the lower class? Isn't the best way to increase lower class incomes to provide them the basic necessities that they spend a portion of their income on already, thus perceptually increasing spending money? Even so, the 5.6 trillion dollars that are controlled by the top 1% of Americans is ripe for the picking. For a businessman, that, say, takes in roughly $1,000,000 a year, would a petty 40% of taxes make any difference to his standards of living? Surely. Yet for a country that grants him the ability to make $1,000,000 a year with its modern economy, superior infrastructure, and brilliant minds, wouldn't we want to work to maintain what incentivizes the big businessman loves to stay in the United States - his roads, his technology at work, his hungry consumer base - his food at a restaurant? Why wouldn't subsidy for the consumer on basic amenities make him hungrier for American products? Who says today's saved tax money for the rich would be spent on employment and development for the companies that spur our domestic economy? Is glutinousness not higher than ever in today's far-fetched standards of extreme luxury?
Perhaps. But however the argument turns out - you're exactly right about the perception of upper-class America, and how we are entering uncharted waters. Anger is mutual! Hopefully, experimentation and careful examination of the best option will prevail.